Best Pizza Around Jacksonville & St. Augustine

  • by Catherine Tortorici
  • February 6, 2024

Jacksonville has so many options for pizza. There are plenty of places that will have something you'll like! This guide has places to go whether you are a vegan,vegetarian, meat eater, or somewhere in-between. Gluten free options are available as well.


Al's Pizza

 Al’s Pizza combines old world quality, values and work ethic with new world ambiance and award winning appeal. They make their dough fresh daily!  Stop by one of their 5 area locations soon and try a slice from one of Jax's best pizza spots!

Wild Pie

Whether you are a meat or plant based pizza lover, Wild Pie Pizza has you covered! We personally loved their Spicy Impossible Meatballs, Roasted Shishito Peppers, Wild Coast Salad, and of course for pizza we dug in to the BBQ Chick'n and Saucy Sausage & Peppers!

Donato's Pizza

Donatos Pizza has one location by Jacksonville Beach. They have a variety of food offered for every dietary restriction. They have a wide variety of pizzas, subs, calzones, appetizers, wings, salads, and desserts. They use fresh ingredients and are always coming up with new things for the menu. 

Photo Credit:@dagmmamarketing


Piccasso’s has a large menu featuring dishes that aren’t typical of Jacksonville such as gumbo and St. Louis style pizza. They feature appetizers,soups,salads,sandwiches, pasta,pizza, and desserts.They are located on San Jose Boulevard.


Taverna offers starters,soups,salads,pastas,entrees,sandwiches,pizza,and desserts.They have many unique pizza flavors including a fungi pizza and a sopressata pizza.Taverna is located on San Marco and they offer free delivery to select zipcodes.


Mama’s Pizza has many options to choose from. They have specialty pizzas, appetizers,salads,chicken wings,calzones,subs,burgers, and more! They also feature Chicago and New York style pizza. They offer gluten free crust and vegan cheese for those with dietary restrictions.They are located on Baymeadows.

Toscana Little Italy

Toscana Little Italy offers something for everyone. They have a variety of appetizers,pastas,pizzas,desserts, and meat entrees.You can dine in or have your meal ready for pickup. They are located on Hendricks Ave.

V Pizza

V Pizza offers weekly specials,shareables,chicken wings,salads,sandwiches,pizzas,calzones, and desserts. On top of that they also have a lunch special and a brunch menu(select locations). Their locations are San Marco,Jacksonville Beach,Mandarin,Fleming Island, and Palm Valley. They also created a non-profit organization called V for Victory which supports local families with cancer.

Joseph’s Pizza

Joseph’s Pizza is a local,family owned restaurant who has served Jacksonville for over 60 years! They have daily specials and brunch(Atlantic Beach location). They offer sandwiches,appetizers,salads,soups, pizzas, and more! They also sell freshly baked bread and homemade sauces and dressings. Joseph’s Pizza is located on North Main St. and Atlantic Beach.

Biggies Pizza

Biggies Pizza has 5 locations around Jacksonville. You can find them at Jacksonville Beach, Riverside, Southside, Ponte Vedra, and Beaches and Hodges. They specialize in New York style pizza, but also have tasty appetizers, salads, heroes, and desserts.



Renna’s Pizza

Renna’s Pizza has New York and Sicilian-style pizza. They also serve appetizers, salads, sandwiches, desserts, and other entrees. They have been around since 1976 and were founded by two Italian brothers. Since then they have grown and are located on South Beach Parkway, Baymeadows, Argyle Village Square, Riverplace Shopping Center, and Neptune Beach.

Photo Credit:@historicavondale

Mellow Mushroom

Mellow Mushroom has a large menu and features so many ways to customize your pizza! They have a vegan and gluten free menu! They also have appetizers,salads,pizzas,calzones,hoagies,burgers,and sweets. Mellow Mushroom also has  meals for home, so you can be prepared for lunch or dinner. They have locations at Jacksonville Beach,Town Center,Avondale,St. Johns,River City, and Fleming Island.

Pie 95

Pie 95 Pizza is where you can find excellent wood-fired pizza! They serve the Jacksonville area with delicious pizza and wings. Pie 95 has a variety of pizza creations that make it easy to find a favorite! They do catering and they update they have a location in Riverside.

Moon River Pizza

Moon River Pizza features hand-cut veggies and hand-made dough. They also stone-bake the  pizza and cook it to perfection. They serve salads, calzones, pizza,bread stix, and specials! They have locations on Edgewood and S. 14th Street.

Catullo's Pizzeria

Catullo's originally started as a food truck. There is a pizzeria on Church Street. They have many pizza options and rollups at the pizzeria. 

Carmines Pie House

Carmines features appetizers,pizzas, calzones, stromboli,salads,subs, and a dinner menu. They also have weekly specials including meatball night and happy hour. You can get a two dollar slice! They are located on  Forbes Street.

Tony D's Pizza & Restaurant

Tony D's has a great menu featuring  appetizers,salads,pizza,calzones, strombolis,pasta,dessert and more! They have pizza and pasta specials on Monday and Tuesday. Tony D's also has catering options.You can find them on Point Meadows Drive.

Pizza Time

Pizza time features garlic rolls, calzones, salads, pizzas, and more. They pride themselves in their Italian food and have over  20 different selections! Some reviewers said that they are always busy and that you should bring cash. They are located in downtown St. Augustine. 

Vinny's Italian Restaurant

Vinny's Italian Restaurant offers appetizers, salads, subs,wraps, pizza, calzones,stromboli, pasta dishes, and more. They offer a Proteinza pizza, sicilian, and many other specialty pies! You can pick up from them. They are located on Beach Boulevard.

More to Check Out

Leaderboard Cafe


Fired Up


Join over 70,000 North Floridian's that receive our weekly newsletter.

Trust us, It's good!

Related Articles